What IS in a Name?

At Barrow Street, perhaps a better question is: Who is in a name? Or, rather, who feels included in a name?

 

As we progressed through choosing a name for our class, two favorites emerged: Golden Girls and Champs of Football, each with roughly equivalent support. Before casting a final vote, we decided to test run each. On Thursday, we used our gym visit to feel out Golden Girls and our roof time to explore Champs of Football. After each experience, we reflected on how it felt to take on those names.

 

The conversation that emerged was fascinating! Several of the boys felt uncomfortable with Golden Girls, since the name felt explicitly specific to just one gender. And while Champs of Football did not seem explicitly gendered at first, many of the boys felt more drawn to it because — in their words — “sports are for boys.” In response, many of the girls thus felt excluded by its use.

 

Quick note on development! In this moment, the children were applying age-appropriate data analysis and categorization. Many of them spent the summer watching the World Cup and as such were inundated with images of only men playing soccer. This offered them a skewed data set that understandably led them to a rigid conclusion. So while the (temporary) conclusion some of them arrived at — “sports are for boys” — was wrong, the process they engaged in to get there is exactly what we expect for this age. See below for how we respond to that particular point.

 

The democratic process we employ to choose a name does sometimes leave voters feeling disappointed if their preferred choice does not win out. But disappointment is very different than excluded. And both these names did cause genuine feelings of exclusion. As such, we did not feel comfortable proceeding to a final vote between them. Whatever name we chose must represent us all.

 

At this point, Marmalade stepped in. First, she sought to dispel the notion that sports are for boys. She shared pictures of championship teams featuring both genders in football and futbol. A counterexample to challenge and expand their data set.

 

The Spanish Men’s National Futbol Team, the Ridgewood High School state champion girls flag football team, the Seattle Seahawks, and the Spanish Women’s National Futbol Team as real world data points.

 

But recognizing that this might not be enough in the moment to make Champs of Football feel fully inclusive, she offered a compromise: The Gold Medals!

 

Why the Gold Medals? Well, the beauty of gold was one of the reasons cited for preferring Golden Girls while medals are used to recognize excellence across domains. So the Gold Medals brought the spirit of both ideas together, felt inclusive to all, and provided an opportunity to celebrate all that make this group special, individually and collectively.

 

Marmalade presented this idea to the students and the response was… mixed. Some liked it, some didn’t. No one felt excluded by it but there was not sufficient consensus to adopt it as our name for the year. So… the work continues! Stay tuned for more next week…